Ninth Circuit’s Opinion in Altera Withdrawn

August 7, 2018 by 1 Comment
0 Flares Filament.io 0 Flares ×

Susan Morse and Steve Shay wrote last week about the significant Ninth Circuit opinion reversing the fully reviewed and unanimously decided Tax Court case in Altera. Earlier today the Ninth Circuit withdrew the July 24th opinion to allow time for a newly reconstituted panel to confer about the appeal.  The order occurred because Judge Stephen Reinhardt, one of the judges in the majority in the 2-1 decision, passed away five months after oral argument and before the publication of the opinion.

On August 2 the court issued an order selecting Judge Susan P. Graber to replace the late Judge Reinhardt on the three-judge panel in the case citing chapter 3.2(h) of the Ninth Circuit General Orders. This section provides that if a member of a three-judge panel becomes unavailable for certain stated reasons , including death, “the Clerk shall draw a replacement as needed, utilizing a list of active judges randomly drawn by lot.”

These events provide even more excitement for a case that did not need more procedural turns to draw attention to its importance.

Filed Under: Administrative Procedure Act (APA)

Comments

  1. Norman Diamond says
    August 7, 2018 at 6:57 pm

    “Earlier today the Ninth Circuit withdrew the July 24th opinion”

    Now you see the advantage of being able to rewire a machine when you find a mistake in it?

    “to allow time for a newly reconstituted panel to confer about the appeal.”

    Oh well. Even if the new judge disagrees with the other two, the result will still stand on a count of two to one. This is what happens when find a mistake and don’t rewire the machine. Courts aren’t alone; some software vendors are known for the same practice. Altera can’t overcome everything.

    Reply

Comment Policy: While we all have years of experience as practitioners and attorneys, and while Keith and Les have taught for many years, we think our work is better when we generate input from others. That is one of the reasons we solicit guest posts (and also because of the time it takes to write what we think are high quality posts). Involvement from others makes our site better. That is why we have kept our site open to comments.

If you want to make a public comment, you must identify yourself (using your first and last name) and register by including your email. If you do not, we will remove your comment. In a comment, if you disagree with or intend to criticize someone (such as the poster, another commenter, a party or counsel in a case), you must do so in a respectful manner. We reserve the right to delete comments. If your comment is obnoxious, mean-spirited or violates our sense of decency we will remove the comment. While you have the right to say what you want, you do not have the right to say what you want on our blog.

Speak Your Mind

*